burrito day 1/26/05
After a long NFL season, we now know the teams for Super Bowl XXXIX -- New England Patriots vs Philadelphia Eagles. In the process, there has been talk about the New England Patriots QB, Tom Brady, becoming the best all-time QB with his 3rd Super Bowl victory. Before this issue can even be addressed, the currrent best all-time QB must be established. The BDC is up to this challenge and is willing to take an unbiased approach. Follow along, and let's see who comes out on top
I think we are all willing to agree that it really comes down to 2 QBs -- John Elway vs. Joe Montana
Let's look at the comparative stats:
Joe Montana John Elway
Games Played 192 234
Wins 117 140 (most all-time)
Yards 40551 51475 (2nd most all-time)
Career Passer Rating 95.3 80.0 (91.2 after Shanahan arrived in 1994)
Touchdowns / Interceptions 273 / 139 300 / 226
Rushing yards / TDs 1676 / 20 3407 / 33
Total TDs per game 1.52 1.42
Super Bowl appearances / Wins 4 / 4 5 / 2
4th Quarter comebacks 33 47 (most all-time)
When it comes down to it, two stats stand out -- 1) Most Wins and 2) 4th
Quarter comebacks. Why? The NFL is about winning. One QB has recorded more wins and has carried his team on his back in the 4th quarter more than anyone else. John Elway clearly stands out in both of these categories. If any member of burrito day was a fan of Elway during this time, they would remember that no game seemed out of reach, no mountain was too high, no pathetic coach or poor supporting crew could inhibit his genius. Time and time again, Elway rose up when
his team needed him most. One could argue that Joe Montana had more Super Bowl wins and a better QB rating, and therefore should be considered the best. However, the BDC offers that both of these stats are strongly influenced by coaching and a talented offense. Until 1993, Elway had neither of these. He played with the Three Amigos (i.e. Vance Johnson, Mark Jackson, and Ricky Nattiel), who were nobodies. Montana, on the other hand, had superstars like Jerry Rice
(undoubtedly the best receiver of all-time) and John Taylor. Montana also had the benefit of Roger Craig for the majority of his career, while Elway was forced to work with Sammy "Mississippi Mudwalk" Winder and Bobby "I beat my wife" Humphrey -- not your all pro running backs! Once Elway had a talented offense (i.e. Terrell Davis, Rod Smith, Shannon Sharpe) and a quality offensive coach, Mike Shanahan (who by the way was the 49ers offensive coordinator / QB coach for the
majority of Montana's career), Elway won two Super Bowls in four years, and his rating improved to something comparable to Montana's Putting everything together -- the answer is clear: JOHN ELWAY is the best QB of all-time ....when playing with a Super Bowl team ...or a very average team. Regardless of the situation, he is a true winner -- simple as that.
Tom Brady is well on his way up the ladder ...but talk to me in 7-8 years after he has experienced some NFL hardship, and let's readdress.
